‘The Hobbit’ – Book Review


My relationship with Tolkien has been sporadic thus far. Ten years ago, the first LOTR film had me asleep in twenty minutes, and although I’ve since been able to (happily) sit through all three, I am trepidatious. Being slightly naive in my reading habits, the opinions of others differ vastly. “Drivel! Unnecessary waffle!” screams one. “Published perfection!” cries another. What to do? I know. I’ll read ‘The Hobbit’. You know? That little one that apparently started it all? It was written for kids right, so how hard could it be?

So I did. And I liked it. I saw the first two films before I opened the front cover so I had the viewing advantage of not hating Peter Jackson for giving botox to an otherwise marvellous story. And it is marvellous. It’s got action, friendship, adventure, and the nicely-rounded morals that characterise a good childrens tale. There are elves, goblins, wolves, eagles, dwarves, a creepy jewellery obsessed dude who lives down a hole, and an unlikely hero in our star performer, Bilbo Baggins. A climactic battle scene gives the reader some mythical closure, and off we go back home with Gandalf the fairy godfather and all round problem fixer.

I didn’t like all the characters: the dwarves I found to be particularly greedy and Smaug the dragon seriously has a deep-seeded superiority complex. And the endless songs, holy moley! Take them out of the book, along with much of the cosmetic final chapter, and it would have achieved a higher rating.

All in all, a delightful read to capture the imagination. Now let’s see how the trilogy compares!


2 thoughts on “‘The Hobbit’ – Book Review

  1. I heard a rumor that the dwarves represent stereotypical Jews in their greediness… whether Tolkein actually meant that is controversial, but he and C.S. Lewis both used a lot of religious themes in their work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s